• The Kids Are Alright – But This Show Isn’t

    by  • September 12, 2018 • ABC, Paleyfest 2018 • 2 Comments

    The Kids Are Alright

    ABC reboots The Real O’Neals – without the gay son.

    In the turbulent decade of the 1970s, the traditional working-class Irish-Catholic Cleary family, tries to navigate the challenges coming their way. Overwhelmed with eight boisterous sons, Mike and Peggy Cleary try to raise their brood with traditional values – an attempt made even more difficult when oldest son Lawrence returns from the seminary and announces he is abandoning his studies for the priesthood so that he can “save the world.”

    Written and produced by The Real O’Neals consulting producer Tim Doyle, The Kids Are Alright is basically The Real O’Neals redux, just set several decades earlier (capitalizing on the popularity of The Goldbergs) and with more sons. Even most of the characters line up with those from Doyle’s earlier work: The Kids Are Alright features the same pushy, overbearing, judgmental mom (she even looks like the mom from The Real O’Neals), the weary, indifferent, blue-collar father, the same doofus older brother, and the same younger brother who is out of step with his family’s traditional masculine interests (he even loves show tunes!)

    Despite the rise of radical politics which split the Democrats (the traditional party of Irish Catholics) in the 1970s, Doyle claims that politics won’t be central to the program – a claim belied by the “fake news” joke included in the first episode. Indeed, it’s difficult to imagine a program set in the 1970s not addressing the political concerns of that era.

    Doyle also claims that the program will be “very respectful” of Catholicism, and won’t be “satirizing or mocking it in any kind of way”…yet this ill comports with the basic premise being a seminarian ditching the priesthood to become a hippie. If this show is anything like The Real O’Neals, a satirical portrayal of Catholicism will be de rigueur. Finally, Doyle claims The Kids Are Alright will be unlike The Real O’Neals in that a gay child won’t be included…or not at first. “It’s not a coming-out story. That’s not part of our immediate plans,” Doyle said.

    Sadly, despite ABC’s alleged commitment to “diversity,” it is clear that with The Middle now concluded, an ABC family comedy that will treat religious working-class families with a modicum of respect is is also gone…and it certainly isn’t being replaced by Doyle’s Real O’Neals reboot. As The Hollywood Reporter’s Daniel Fienberg put it, “Of all of ABC’s ABC-y shows, this is easily the ABC-iest.”

    The Kids Are Alright premieres Tuesday, October 16 on ABC.



    Christopher Gildemeister is the PTC’s Head of Research Operations. He began as an Entertainment Analyst at the PTC in 2005. From 2007-2016, he was Senior Writer/Editor, responsible for communicating the PTC’s message to the public through newsletters, columns, and the PTC Watchdog blog. Dr. Gildemeister holds a Ph.D. from The Catholic University of America.

    2 Responses to The Kids Are Alright – But This Show Isn’t

    1. Irish
      April 15, 2019 at 11:29 am

      This is a great show. It is about his actual life. My husband and myself who grew up in large Catholic families(mine Irish, his Italian) find a lot of familiar in the show. I find that everyone in the show holds Catholic to a high respectable standard. There have been serious conversations about sermons and what they mean. It is a show of its time. The 70s was a changing time.

    2. September 13, 2018 at 12:27 am

      Tim Doyle’s hypocrisy is showing!

      And I agree on what you said. The Kids are Alright is pretty much The Real O’Neals 2.0, even down to the Irish-Catholic family. Even though there wasn’t explicit sex talk in the first episode, there might be potential for it to increase in the future, just like how O’Neals featured explicit sex talk.

      In short, you can skip this trash.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *